News
When Homeowners Withhold Assessments: What Utah HOAs Should Know
Imagine this: A homeowner has been asking their HOA to fix a landscaping issue for months. Frustrated by the lack of progress, they decide to take matters into their own hands. Rather than continuing to pay their monthly assessments, they stop paying altogether, reasoning that if the HOA isn’t doing its job, why should they?
It’s a situation many HOA boards and property managers have encountered. Whether the complaint involves neglected landscaping, delayed repairs, or dissatisfaction with the board’s decisions, some homeowners believe withholding assessments is an effective way to force their association to take action.
But can a homeowner legally stop paying assessments because they’re unhappy with their HOA? Under Utah law, the answer is generally no.
A Homeowner’s Obligation to Pay Assessments
Both Utah’s Community Association Act and Condominium Ownership Act establish the legal framework for collecting assessments from homeowners and condominium unit owners. However, an association’s governing documents, particularly its Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs), are equally important.
The CC&Rs typically establish the homeowner’s obligation to pay assessments, explain how assessments are allocated among properties, and outline the association’s authority to collect unpaid amounts. Because these obligations are generally tied to ownership of property within the community, homeowners cannot simply opt out of paying assessments when they disagree with the board. These assessments are essential to an association’s ability to operate. From landscaping and snow removal to insurance and common area repairs, associations rely on regular payments to meet their financial obligations. When one homeowner stops paying, the association still has to cover those expenses, potentially leaving the other homeowners to make up the difference.
Importantly, a homeowner’s obligation to pay assessments generally exists independently of the association’s obligation to maintain and repair common areas. In other words, a homeowner cannot ordinarily stop paying assessments simply because they believe the association isn’t holding up its end of the bargain.
What if the Homeowner Has a Legitimate Complaint?
Of course, homeowners aren’t always wrong about their complaints. Associations have responsibilities under Utah law and their governing documents, including certain obligations to maintain and repair common areas. For example, if an association is responsible for maintaining a common area and fails to do so, the homeowner may have a legitimate grievance. However, that does not automatically give the homeowner the right to withhold assessments.
The two issues are generally separate. Homeowners may have legal remedies available to address an association’s failure to meet its obligations, but withholding assessments can create an entirely new problem without resolving the original dispute. For HOA boards, the takeaway is simple: A homeowner’s obligation to pay assessments does not disappear simply because they have a complaint against the association. At the same time, boards should take legitimate complaints seriously rather than dismissing them because the homeowner is delinquent.
What Happens When a Homeowner Refuses to Pay?
Utah law gives homeowners associations and condominium associations several tools to address unpaid assessments, but the first place boards and property managers should look is their association’s CC&Rs. These documents typically establish the association’s authority to collect assessments and outline the remedies available when homeowners fail to pay.
Depending on the governing documents and applicable law, associations may impose late fees and interest on unpaid assessments and recover certain collection costs and attorney fees. As a result, a homeowner who initially refuses to pay a few hundred dollars in assessments could ultimately face a much larger balance as these additional charges accumulate.
Beyond these financial consequences, Utah law also provides associations with several collection remedies. Both the Community Association Act and Condominium Ownership Act establish lien rights against properties for unpaid assessments. Associations may also pursue a personal money judgment against the homeowner or, in certain circumstances, enforce their lien through foreclosure, subject to applicable legal requirements.
Before pursuing collections, however, boards and property managers should carefully review their CC&Rs to ensure that the assessments and related charges are properly authorized. They should also confirm that any required notices and collection procedures have been followed. Even when an association has a valid claim for unpaid assessments, failing to comply with its governing documents or applicable Utah law can complicate collection efforts.
A Step-by-Step Process for Handling Assessment Disputes
When a homeowner stops paying assessments over a disagreement with the association, there are several steps boards and property managers should consider before the dispute escalates.
First, address the underlying complaint. Even if the homeowner is required to continue paying assessments, the association should still evaluate whether the complaint has merit. Ignoring a legitimate maintenance issue can escalate an otherwise manageable dispute and ultimately backfire on the Association.
Second, communicate clearly. Explain to the homeowner that their assessment obligations remain in effect while their complaint is being addressed. A written response can help avoid misunderstandings and establish a record of the association’s efforts to resolve the issue.
Third, review the governing documents and document everything. Make sure the association’s CC&Rs authorize the assessments and applicable collection charges. Some CC&Rs also contain provisions expressly stating that a homeowner’s obligation to pay assessments is independent of the association’s obligation to perform maintenance or provide services. Boards and property managers should look for this type of language, as it can be particularly helpful when responding to homeowners who attempt to justify withholding assessments based on the association’s alleged failure to fulfill its responsibilities.
Additionally, maintain accurate account statements, copies of collection notices, and records of communications with the homeowner. Good documentation can make a significant difference if the dispute eventually results in litigation, which ultimately helps keep attorney fees lower and more manageable.
Finally, enforce collection policies consistently. Associations should follow their established collection procedures rather than making arbitrary exceptions or delaying enforcement simply because a homeowner has raised complaints. Consistent application of collection policies helps protect the association and ensures that other homeowners are not unfairly burdened. If your association does not already have a formal collection policy in place, adopting one is highly recommended. A well-drafted collection policy helps establish clear procedures for handling delinquent accounts and ensures that assessments are collected consistently and in accordance with applicable law. Our firm is happy to assist associations in developing and implementing a collection policy tailored to their governing documents and needs.
Protecting Your Association Moving Forward
Disagreements between homeowners and their associations are inevitable, but withholding assessments is generally not an appropriate way to resolve those disputes.
For HOA boards and property managers, the important distinction is that an association’s maintenance responsibilities and a homeowner’s assessment obligations are generally separate. While legitimate homeowner complaints should be addressed, they do not ordinarily excuse a homeowner from paying assessments.
Ultimately, boards should treat assessment delinquencies and homeowner complaints as separate issues. Address the complaint on its merits, but continue to enforce the homeowner’s assessment obligations in accordance with the association’s governing documents and applicable Utah law.
HOA Rules vs. CC&Rs: Why the Difference Matters
Homeowners associations (HOAs) rely on several governing documents, including declarations (CC&Rs), bylaws, and rules and regulations. Although these documents work together, each serves a different purpose.
HOA boards sometimes adopt rules without fully considering whether they have the authority to do so under the association’s governing documents or applicable Utah law. This can happen because adopting a rule is often procedurally simpler than amending the declaration, which may require approval from the membership.
A board’s rulemaking authority, however, is not unlimited. Rules generally cannot override or contradict the declaration. Boards must ensure that new rules are consistent with the association’s governing documents and applicable law.
1. What Is the Difference Between CC&Rs and HOA Rules?
CC&Rs
The declaration generally establishes the fundamental rights and responsibilities of homeowners and the association. It often addresses matters such as property use, maintenance responsibilities, assessments, architectural restrictions, and enforcement authority.
The declaration is recorded against the properties within the association and generally runs with the land, meaning its provisions may continue to apply when ownership changes.
Rules and Regulations
Rules and regulations generally address the day-to-day operation of the association and regulate matters within the board’s authority. Examples may include pool hours, parking procedures, clubhouse reservations, and trash disposal.
Unlike the declaration, which typically establishes the community’s fundamental restrictions and obligations, rules often provide more detailed requirements for the use and operation of the community. Rules are generally not recorded against individual properties and may be adopted by the board when authorized by the governing documents and applicable law.
2. Can HOA Rules Conflict With the CC&Rs?
Generally, a board cannot use its rulemaking authority to override or contradict the declaration. Although an HOA board may have authority to adopt rules governing the community, that authority is subject to the declaration and applicable law.
A board generally cannot use a rule to circumvent the declaration or make a change that requires a formal amendment.
For example, if the declaration expressly grants homeowners a particular property right, the board generally cannot eliminate that right through a new rule. Similarly, if the declaration establishes specific parking rights, the board generally cannot eliminate those rights simply by adopting a parking rule.
The declaration may, however, grant the board authority to adopt rules addressing certain matters in greater detail. In those circumstances, a rule may impose additional requirements as long as it remains within the authority granted by the governing documents and does not conflict with applicable law.
The key question is whether the rule reasonably regulates a matter within the board’s existing authority or instead attempts to change a right or restriction established by the declaration.
Importantly, not every restriction adopted through a rule necessarily conflicts with the declaration. For example, a declaration may provide that street parking is prohibited unless otherwise permitted by a rule adopted by the board. In that situation, the declaration expressly grants the board authority to regulate street parking through rules.
A rule permitting or restricting street parking within the scope of that authority would not necessarily conflict with the declaration. The important distinction is whether the declaration authorizes the board to regulate the particular matter or whether the proposed rule attempts to change a right or restriction established by the declaration.
3. What Happens When an HOA Adopts a Rule Without Proper Authority?
Adopting a rule without proper authority can create confusion and disputes within the community. Homeowners may challenge the rule, and the association may have difficulty enforcing it if the rule exceeds the board’s authority or conflicts with the governing documents.
These disputes can also result in unnecessary legal expenses for the association. Before attempting to enforce a disputed rule, the board should review the rule’s validity and determine whether it was properly adopted and falls within the board’s authority.
4. What Should HOA Boards Do Before Adopting New Rules?
Before adopting a new rule, HOA boards should:
- Review the governing documents. Identify the provisions that authorize the board to adopt rules and determine whether the proposed rule falls within that authority.
- Check for conflicts. Confirm that the proposed rule is consistent with the declaration, bylaws, and applicable law.
- Determine whether an amendment is necessary. Consider whether the proposed change would alter an existing right or restriction and therefore require a formal amendment rather than a board-adopted rule.
- Follow the proper procedures. Ensure that the board follows all applicable requirements for adopting and communicating the rule.
- Consult legal counsel when necessary. If the board is uncertain about its authority or whether a proposed rule conflicts with the governing documents, it should seek legal guidance before proceeding.
Conclusion
Although adopting rules is often simpler than amending the declaration, rules are not a shortcut for changing the association’s governing documents. A board must exercise its rulemaking authority within the limits established by the declaration and applicable law.
Before adopting a new rule, boards should consider whether they are regulating a matter already within their authority or attempting to change an existing right or restriction. Making that distinction before adopting a rule can help prevent disputes, avoid unnecessary legal expenses, and ensure that the association’s governing documents work together as intended.
What the New Fannie Mae & Freddie Mac Guidelines Mean for Condominiums in 2026 and Beyond
Navigating condominium financing can feel like trying to hit a moving target. For Condominium Owner Associations (COAs), board members, and prospective buyers, staying on top of lending criteria set by federal regulators is crucial.
Recently, the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA)—which oversees mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac—introduced key policy shifts that directly impact condo project eligibility, market liquidity, and board budgeting.
Below is a breakdown of what these changes mean for your community, existing owners, and future buyers.
The Big News: Retirement of the 50% Investment Concentration Limit
Historically, one of the biggest roadblocks preventing established condo projects from obtaining Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac eligibility was the 50% investment property concentration limit. Under the old rule, at least 50% of the units in a project had to be owner-occupied. If investor ownership crept above half, the entire project risked becoming “non-warrantable,” shutting out buyers who relied on conventional, lower-cost financing.
What Changed?
Effective May 18, 2026, Fannie Mae officially retired the 50% investment concentration limit for established projects.
- For Existing Owners: Projects previously disqualified due to high rental rates now have a clearer path toward FHFA and conventional loan eligibility—including Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae. Opening up conventional financing increases the pool of potential buyers, which helps protect unit values and overall liquidity.
- For Investors: Existing owners looking to acquire additional units within an established project can now do so under standard financing terms without triggering project-wide disqualification.
Note on New Construction: The old rules still apply to new developments. For brand-new projects, the presale requirement remains: at least 50% of unit sales must be to principal residence or second-home purchasers (Lender Letter LL-2026-03).
Stricter Financial & Review Standards (August 2026)
While the removal of investment caps offers relief, Fannie Mae has simultaneously tightened financial scrutiny in other critical areas:
- Elimination of “Limited Reviews”: Initially introduced under temporary guidelines in the wake of the Surfside collapse, the limited review policies and updates regarding structural integrity, deferred maintenance, and special assessments have been eliminated. This applies only to Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac conventional lending standards, not all mortgage types across the board. Starting August 3, 2026, limited reviews for Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac are a thing of the past. Every condominium project must now undergo a Full Review, regardless of the size of the buyer’s down payment. Lenders will now consistently require:
- A full COA budget
- A completed condo project questionnaire
- Proof of adequate insurance coverage
- Verification of reserve funds
- Details on delinquent assessment accounts and pending litigation
- Tighter Reserve Study Rules: If a lender relies on a Reserve Study to evaluate a project’s financial stability (often necessary when a COA’s regular budget falls short of standard requirements), Fannie Mae now mandates that the board’s operating budget include the highest recommended reserve allocation specified in that study.
Looking Ahead: Reserve Requirements Hike (January 2027)
COA boards need to start planning now for upcoming changes to operating reserve floors. Note that these changes apply to conventional mortgage financing backed by Fannie Mae/applFreddie Mac (FHFA), and do not alter government-backed loan programs like FHA or VA:
- 15% Reserve Requirement: Beginning January 4, 2027, mandatory reserve allocations will increase from 10% to 15% of the COA’s operating budget.
- Action Required for Boards: Communities currently maintaining their reserve contributions at the minimum 10% floor will need to adjust their budgets—which may require raising member assessments to meet the 15% threshold. Failing to adjust could render the project non-warrantable unless it meets the strict Reserve Study criteria outlined above.
What Should COA Boards Do Next?
- Review Your Budget Early: Examine your current reserve contributions. If you are funding at or near 10%, plan for the jump to 15% before 2027.
- Obtain or Update Your Reserve Study: Ensure your reserve allocations align with professional recommendations to keep financing options open for buyers.
- Prepare Your Documentation: Because all sales will now require a full review, ensure your association’s financial statements, questionnaire records, and litigation disclosures are organized and up to date.
If you have questions about how these updated FHFA guidelines impact your association, legal obligations, or financial planning, reach out to the legal team at Miller Harrison for guidance.
When an HOA Hits a Governance Roadblock: Using Utah Code § 16-6a-117 to Move Forward
Homeowners associations can encounter situations where their governing documents require a meeting, vote, consent, or other member action that becomes impractical or impossible to achieve.
For example, an association may be seeking approval of amended governing documents but unable to obtain participation from enough owners to reach the required threshold. The proposed amendments may be strongly supported by those owners who do participate, but continued nonresponse from a portion of the membership prevents adoption. The same issue may arise with a special assessment or another action that depends on member participation or consent. In some circumstances, the difficulty may involve the association’s ability to properly call or conduct a required meeting rather than a vote.
When good-faith, repeated efforts are not enough to move an association forward, Utah law provides another option. Because homeowners associations are generally organized as nonprofit corporations, Utah Code § 16-6a-117 of the Utah Revised Nonprofit Corporation Act provides a mechanism for judicial relief when the association’s ordinary governance process has become impractical or impossible to complete.
What is Utah Code § 16-6a-117?
Section 16-6a-117 applies when it has become impractical or impossible for a nonprofit corporation to call or conduct a meeting of its members, delegates, or directors, or otherwise obtain their consent in the manner ordinarily required.
The statute allows a director, officer, delegate, or member to petition the court for relief. If relief is appropriate, the court has broad discretion to enter an order that is fair and equitable under the circumstances. Depending on the situation, that may include authorizing a meeting, written consent, or another method of obtaining the necessary approval. The court may also dispense with applicable quorum or voting thresholds.
That flexibility is what makes § 16-6a-117 so useful. But it does not mean every difficult vote or governance problem is a good candidate for a 16-6a-117 petition.
A Petition Needs a Strong Factual Record
The key question is not simply whether the association has been unsuccessful, but why. A petition should be supported by facts showing that the association has made diligent, repeated efforts to use its ordinary procedures and that continuing the same process is unlikely to resolve the problem. This helps establish that the circumstances have become impractical or impossible, as required by the statute.
Where owner participation is the issue, relevant facts may include prior voting periods, extensions, notices, meetings, emails, phone calls, direct outreach, and the actual voting results. The distinction between nonparticipation and opposition can also matter. An association that has strong support among participating owners but cannot obtain enough responses to reach the required threshold presents a different situation from one in which a significant number of owners have affirmatively opposed the proposed action.
Other cases may involve a different type of obstacle, and the relevant facts will depend on what the association is trying to accomplish and what is preventing it from doing so.
The important point is that § 16-6a-117 is not intended to replace the association’s normal procedures simply because they present challenges or require additional time and effort. The association should be able to show why continued use of those procedures has become impractical or impossible and why judicial involvement is warranted.
What Does a Petition Include, and What Does the Process Look Like?
If the circumstances support moving forward, a petition should, at a minimum, explain the applicable governance requirements, an association’s prior efforts, why continued use of the process required by the governing documents has become impractical or impossible, and the specific relief requested.
Following the filing of the petition and the required procedural steps, an association will typically submit a proposed order setting out the requested relief. The proposed order should also include a method of notice reasonably designed to reach those who would otherwise be entitled to notice of the meeting or action. The court then determines whether the requested relief is fair and equitable under the circumstances and whether to enter the order.
Section 16-6a-117 gives an association flexibility to request relief directed toward addressing the circumstances that have made it impractical or impossible to proceed via the process required by its governing documents. Where applicable, the statute is also intended to provide long-term solutions that allow an association to continue managing its affairs without having to seek relief under Section 16-6a-117 again. If relief is granted, the association may then proceed in accordance with the court’s order, including any notice, action, voting, meeting, or other requirements established by the court.
Is Your Association Ready to File?
Sometimes the answer is yes. Sometimes the better answer is not yet.
Before filing, an association should evaluate what it is trying to accomplish, what requirement is preventing it from moving forward, what has already been attempted, and whether additional reasonable efforts could make a difference.
In some cases, the association may already have a well-developed history supporting judicial relief. In others, another targeted outreach effort, owner meeting, voting extension, or better documentation may help either resolve the problem or strengthen the record for a future petition.
That evaluation is important. A petition is only as strong as the facts supporting it.
Could Section 16-6a-117 Help Your Association?
An association does not necessarily have to continue repeating a required process once the circumstances have reached the point where doing so may be impractical or impossible. At the same time, obtaining relief under § 16-6a-117 will depend on the particular facts and the record supporting the request.
Miller Harrison works with homeowners associations to evaluate whether a petition may be appropriate, including reviewing the governing documents, prior voting or outreach efforts, the factual record, and the circumstances preventing an association from moving forward. Where additional steps may strengthen the record before filing, we can also help identify and structure those efforts.
If your association has been unable to obtain a required vote or consent, establish a quorum, conduct a required meeting, or otherwise complete an important governance action, contact our office to discuss whether relief under Utah Code § 16-6a-117 may be appropriate for your association.
The Meaning of ‘Single Family’
“There’s a group of unrelated college students living in a house in our neighborhood. Our governing documents say that houses can only be used as single-family homes. Aren’t these roommates violating those provisions?”
The answer is no. Unrelated roommates living together in a home are not necessarily in violation of a restriction requiring all homes to be used for single-family use. This is because, under the law, “family” might not mean what you think it means.
Denying someone housing because they are not married to the person they are living with, not related to the person they are living with, have no children, or are living alone would violate the law. Even though local zoning laws and HOA governing documents will usually use the term “single family” (or “one family,” which is common in Utah), they are not necessarily referring to actual families. This is one of those times when legal speak doesn’t follow common sense.
The legal definition of “family” varies a little depending on the body of law you are dealing with. For instance, in Utah, state statutes do not define the term, but individual municipalities do. Although the definitions used by different municipalities vary, they are generally similar because they all rely on the same case law and codified law that have developed on both federal and state levels over time. The City of Orem provides a good example:
Family shall mean one of the following groups of individuals, but not more than one at the same time: (1) an individual living alone; or (2) two or more people all of whom are related to one designated occupant of the dwelling by blood, marriage, adoption, or legal guardianship and their foster children and up to two other unrelated persons who do not pay rent and are not the primary occupant(s) of the dwelling; or (3) up to three related or unrelated individuals who live and cook together as a single housekeeping unit; or (4) two unrelated individuals and any children of either of them living as a single-housekeeping unit; (5) up to six unrelated individuals living in the Student Housing Overlay zone or PD-21 zone; or (6) a number of unrelated individuals as may be specifically indicated in a particular PD zone.
For purposes of this section, primary occupant(s) is defined as the owner of the dwelling (owner is as defined in Section 22-6-9(I)(2)) and all persons related to the owner, or, if the owner does not live in the dwelling, the primary occupant(s)shall mean the person(s) to whom the owner has leased the dwelling and all persons related to the lessee. The definition of family includes up to two guests if the guests live and cook together with the family in a single dwelling unit and do not pay rent or give other consideration for the privilege of staying with the family. A guest under this section is defined as a person who stays with a family for a period of less than thirty days within any rolling one year period and does not utilize the dwelling as a legal address for any purpose. For purposes of the definition of family, the term “related” shall mean a spouse, parent, child, grandparent, grandchild, brother, sister, uncle, aunt, nephew, niece, great-grandparent, and great-grandchild. The term “related” does not include other, more distant relationships such as cousins.
As stated in Orem’s definition, the term “family” can refer to a variety of groups including any group of 3 or less unrelated persons who live and cook together as a single housekeeping unit.
The bottom line for community association boards is, when you see the term “single family” in your governing documents, make sure you understand exactly what it is referring to. Go online and become familiar with your municipality’s definition (or have your attorney explain it to you). The best practice is to have a definition for “family” or “single family” in your governing documents that is consistent with the definition used by your local municipality, or just have your documents refer to the local ordinance. Your documents should also contain some detail about what constitutes a housing use violation. For instance, although you usually can’t deny housing based on the relationship between residents, you may restrict how many people live in a unit based on legitimate health and safety considerations. If your governing documents do not include these provisions and details, you should consider amending to include them.
Utah Reinvestment Fees: What HOAs Need to Know About the 2026 Changes
Utah homeowners associations have long used reinvestment fees as a way to generate revenue when property is sold to help fund the costs of maintaining community amenities and infrastructure. The Utah Legislature recently made changes to how reinvestment fees may be established, calculated, and used.
What Is a Reinvestment Fee?
A reinvestment fee is a fee imposed on a buyer or seller when real property within a common-interest community is transferred. Under Utah Code § 57-1-46, the fee must be dedicated to benefiting the common areas or the community, including expenses associated with infrastructure, amenities, open space, recreation facilities, community programming, association expenses, and certain capital-intensive infrastructure maintenance.
Reinvestment fees are different from ordinary HOA transfer or administrative fees. A transfer-related administrative fee is generally intended to cover the association’s costs associated with processing a sale, while a reinvestment fee is a covenant-based charge intended to provide funding for the community itself.
New Cap on Reinvestment Fees
For most associations, the maximum reinvestment fee that can be charged is 0.5% of the value of the property. However, this year the Legislature created a new category called a “low-amenity association.” A low-amenity association is generally an association consisting exclusively of detached single-family homes that does not provide capital-intensive infrastructure maintenance services to its members. For these associations, the cap is reduced to 0.25% of the property’s value.
For example, on a $500,000 home:
- A typical qualifying association could charge up to $2,500.
- A low-amenity association could only charge up to $1,250.
The statutory caps do not apply to property located within a “large master planned development” (i.e. more than 500 acres or 500 homes).
At Least 50% Must Go Into Reserves
The new law also changes how reinvestment-fee revenue must be handled. Unless the association is a large master planned development, at least 50% of each reinvestment fee must be deposited into reserve funds. This change is particularly important for communities that have historically treated reinvestment-fee revenue as general operating revenue. Going forward, associations subject to the requirement should establish accounting procedures that clearly identify the portion of reinvestment-fee revenue that must be reserved for future capital needs.
Member Approval Is Now Required
The 2026 amendments also impose a new approval requirement. Beginning May 6, 2026, an association may not impose a reinvestment fee unless:
- The fee is authorized by the declaration or a reinvestment fee covenant; and
- A majority of the association’s voting interests, or a greater percentage required by the governing documents, approves the fee.
After the required approval, the association may establish the amount of the fee only in accordance with the declaration or reinvestment fee covenant and applicable notice requirements.
Owners Can Also Vote to Remove or Amend the Fee
The new statute gives association members a mechanism to challenge or modify an existing reinvestment fee. Members may call a special meeting to consider removing or amending the fee. At least 51% of the voting interests must attend and vote, and a majority of those voting must approve the change.
What Should Utah HOAs Do Now?
The 2026 amendments make it important for HOAs, condominium associations, and developers to review their existing reinvestment-fee provisions. In particular, associations should determine:
- Whether the reinvestment fee is properly authorized in the recorded governing documents;
- Whether a separate statutory notice of the reinvestment-fee covenant has been recorded;
- Whether the association qualifies as a low-amenity association;
- Whether the existing fee exceeds the applicable statutory cap;
- Whether the association’s accounting procedures properly segregate the required reserve contribution; and
- Whether the association has obtained the member approval when required.
For new developments, these changes should also be considered when drafting declarations, reinvestment fee covenants, budgets, and reserve plans. Reinvestment fees can provide a valuable source of long-term funding, particularly for communities with substantial amenities or capital-intensive infrastructure, but the covenant now needs to be structured with the new statutory provisions in mind.
Will the Real HOA Please Stand Up? Navigating HOA Trademarks and Domain Name Drama
Imagine this: Your homeowners association, let’s call it Whispering Pines Lodge HOA, has been operating smoothly for years. But recently, a board member does a quick internet search and discovers a shiny new website—whisperingpineslodge.com—run by a third-party property management company or a local real estate agent renting out units in your community.
Suddenly, your residents and potential buyers are confused. Is this the official HOA website? Who is actually in charge here?

Before you brace yourselves for aggressive (and expensive) litigation, let’s break down the legal realities of HOA trademarks and look at some practical, cost-effective steps to protect your community’s identity.
The Basics: Common Law vs. Federal Trademarks
First things first. Does an HOA need a federal trademark to protect their name? The short answer is: No, but it’s complicated.
Under U.S. law, a trademark is acquired the moment a mark (like your HOA’s name or logo) is used in commerce. This grants the owner the right to prevent others from using confusingly similar marks. This is called a “common law” trademark, and it apply to marks currently used within a specific geographic area. You don’t actually need to file paperwork in Washington D.C. to get this basic protection.
Because your HOA has likely used its name since the day the Declaration was recorded, the Association almost certainly holds common law trademark rights over its full, official name in the local area.
If a court were to look at a potential infringement, they would evaluate whether the competing use causes a “likelihood of consumer confusion,” dilutes the value of your name, or implies that the HOA has authorized or endorsed the third party. This is also the HOA’s concern; members may stumble onto copies governing documents or rules on a third-party website and be led astray by outdated information.
The “Gray Area” of Generic, Common Words
Here’s where things get tricky. While you might own the rights to your full HOA name, claiming exclusive rights to individual, common words is an uphill battle.
If your community is called Whispering Pines Lodge, each of the individual words, “Whispering,” “Pines,” and “Lodge” are incredibly common. These are words used in everyday speech, so legally preventing a third party from using those individual words is very difficult. Combining multiple words is a good start at becoming more unique. Whispering Pines Lodge puts you in a legal gray area. The combination of these words is a little less common, but someone is likely using a similar name somewhere on the internet. However, as an existing HOA using the name in the area, you will have some protection. Pro tip: the more unique the name, the easier to protect.
Domains are Not Trademarks
It’s easy to assume that if you own the trademark, you should automatically own the domain. Unfortunately, the internet doesn’t work that way.
In a legal sense, a domain name is treated as a form of intangible property; it’s just a digital address. While a trademark can be used as a domain, you generally cannot stop someone else from registering a domain name that incorporates common words, as long as they aren’t using it to actively deceive consumers or sell counterfeit goods.
While the HOA could try to buy up every competing domain name, paying to acquire and maintain a bunch of dormant websites is rarely a prudent use of association funds.
Practical Remedies That Won’t Break the Bank
If an aggressive lawsuit isn’t the answer, what should an HOA do when a third party is piggybacking off their name? Here is the Miller Harrison approach:
1. Send a Letter
If online confusion is a real concern, we recommend sending a formal letter to the third-party property managers or agents. Trademark law rewards those who actively prevent others from using their mark. The letter will officially request that they modify their website to clarify they are notaffiliated with the Association. Usually, adding a simple disclaimer, providing a direct link to the official HOA site, or explicitly identifying themselves as a third-party manager is enough to solve the problem.

2. Leverage SEO Instead of Lawsuits.
If your HOA website is buried on page three of Google for the search term “Whispering Pines Lodge Utah” but pulls up first for “Whispering Pines Lodge Utah HOA”, the most practical solution is Search Engine Optimization (SEO). Investing a little time or money into improving your official site’s SEO will ensure it pops up first when owners are looking for you. It’s can often be much cheaper to outrank the competition on Google than it is to out-litigate them in court.
3. Consider Federal Registration (If It Makes Sense)
Federal trademark registration remains an option. While not strictly necessary, it provides stronger enforcement rights across the entire country and puts the public on official notice of your ownership. The process involves an application, a review period by the USPTO, and a public opposition period. Even then, it’s not a magic shield. It only protects you in specific categories of commerce and doesn’t give you a monopoly on generic words. Still, if you want to solidify your priority, it’s a tool worth considering.
The Bottom Line
When it comes to HOA name confusion, you have rights, but you also have options that don’t require draining your reserve accounts on legal fees.
If your community is dealing with digital doppelgängers, a well-drafted letter and a smart web strategy are usually your best bets. If you need help drafting that letter, evaluating your common law rights, or applying for a federal trademark, the team at Miller Harrison is here to help. Contact us today to keep your HOA’s good name exactly where it belongs—with you.
What Utah HOAs Need to Know About Records Requests
If you’re reading this and your HOA’s records consist of an envelope of receipts, loose dollars, and a picture of the Board President from 2001, keep reading. If you’re reading this and your HOA’s records are dialed in, neatly sorted, alphabetized, color-coded, and digitally easy to find, keep reading. You see, no matter the state of your HOA’s records, the dreaded records request will come for us all. Don’t be scared. We just need to make sure you’re ready.
An Owner’s Requirements for a Records Request
Owners want to ensure that their HOA is a well-oiled machine. In order to get access to certain records, an owner must submit a properly formatted written request. A casual verbal comment at a board meeting or a vague text to a board member doesn’t trigger the statutory penalties. Under Utah Code § 57-8a-227(3)(a), the owner’s written request must explicitly include:
- The Association’s Name
- The Owner’s Full Name
- The Property Address
- The Owner’s Email Address
- A Clear Description of the specific documents requested
Additionally, under § 57-8a-227(3)(b), the owner must specify their election on how they want to receive or view the records. If a request is missing these core statutory elements, a board can ask the owner to resubmit a compliant written request before spending association resources compiling documents. Whether a request stems from genuine curiosity or an escalating dispute over vendor contracts, ignoring or improperly handling a member’s demand for documents can quickly turn an administrative minor hassle into a costly legal headache. Utah Code Section 57-8a-227 sets the ground rules for community associations that has mostly been straightforward. But a notable shift from the Utah HOA Ombudsman’s Office has shifted the landscape on what associations must hand over.
Why HOAs Must Respond and How Fast
Under Utah Code § 57-8a-227, homeowners have a clear statutory right to inspect and copy core association documents.
- The Timeline: An association has 10 business days from receipt of a written request to comply.
- The Core Documents: The statutory list includes recorded CC&Rs, bylaws, rules, approved meeting minutes (past 3 years), insurance certificates, reserve analyses, and annual financial statements.
Failing to respond within the statutory window is rarely a winning strategy:
- For failing to provide core website-required documents (governing documents, recent minutes, and annual budgets/financials), the HOA incurs a mandatory $25 per day penalty paid to the owner, starting on the 11th business day.
- If an owner sends a 10-day cure notice and the board fails to fix the issue, the owner can file a lawsuit. If they win, the court can order production, award actual damages (or $1,000, whichever is greater), and force the HOA to pay the owner’s attorney fees.
The Ombudsman’s Plot Twist
While § 57-8a-227 requires associations to provide “appropriate accounting records” under Utah Code § 16-6a-1601(2), the term itself has long been a grey area. Previously, many associations operated under the assumption that providing high-level financial summary reports—like annual profit-and-loss statements and balance sheets—was enough to satisfy the statute. However, in Advisory Opinion 2026-28 (issued July 14, 2026), the Utah HOA Ombudsman expressly reconsidered its prior position and introduced significant clarity—and confusion—for board operations:
- Financial Statements ≠ Accounting Records: The Ombudsman clarified that high-level summary reports and “appropriate accounting records” are distinctly different.
- Executed Contracts & Invoices MUST Be Produced: The Ombudsman ruled that transaction-level source documents used to build the budget or verify financial statements—including executed vendor contracts, invoices, receipts, and general ledgers—are “appropriate accounting records” that an HOA must provide upon request.
- Where the Line Is Drawn: The Ombudsman drew a firm boundary around unexecuted bids and vendor proposals. Drafts, unaccepted bids, or rejected proposals that never created a financial obligation for the association do not constitute accounting records and do not have to be disclosed.
What This Means for Your Board’s Best Practices
This shift means boards cannot simply point an owner to an online budget spreadsheet and consider the matter closed if the owner asks to see the underlying vendor contracts supporting those budget line items.
- To protect your association, boards should adopt these best practices immediately:
- Maintain neat, auditable digital records of all executed contracts, paid invoices, and bank statements alongside your monthly financials.
- Store unaccepted vendor bids in separate administrative files so they aren’t accidentally commingled or improperly disclosed.
- Date-stamp every written request upon arrival to ensure your 10-business-day compliance clock doesn’t run out unnoticed.
If your association has received a complex records request or wants to audit its document retention policy under the latest Utah rulings, reach out to the legal team at Miller Harrison today. We’ll help keep your books clean, your responses timely, and your board out of the crosshairs.
Utah HOA Special Assessments: Getting the Assessment and Financing Right
In our last article, we discussed the different ways Utah HOAs and condominium associations can fund major repairs, including operating funds, reserves, and special assessments. When a board determines that a special assessment is necessary, two important questions usually follow:
- How do we make sure the assessment is legally valid?
- Can we fund the project now without requiring every owner to come up with a large lump sum payment immediately?
The answers to those questions depend on Utah law and the association’s governing documents. The declaration and bylaws may determine whether the board can approve the assessment on its own or whether an owner vote is required. The governing documents and Utah law also impose specific requirements for notice, voting, allocation of the assessment, and payment. For larger projects, an association loan can also be a useful tool. When structured properly, a loan can allow the association to complete needed work promptly while giving owners who need additional time the ability to pay their assessments over a longer period. But both pieces need to be done correctly. An improperly authorized assessment can create collection and enforcement problems. Poorly negotiated loan documents can also give a lender rights that are unnecessarily broad or require the board to make commitments that exceed its authority under the governing documents.
Making Sure the Special Assessment Is Properly Authorized
Before imposing a significant special assessment, the board should answer several basic questions such as:
- Does the board have authority to approve the assessment, or is an owner vote required?
- How must the assessment be allocated among the owners?
- Are there limits on the amount, timing, or purpose of the assessment?
- 4. What meeting, notice, and voting procedures apply?
Some governing documents allow the board to impose a special assessment without an owner vote. Others require owner approval, particularly for assessments above a certain amount or for particular types of expenses. The board should also verify how the cost must be divided. An equal division among lots or units may seem fair, but the declaration may require the expense to be allocated according to ownership interests, percentages, unit types, or another formula. Utah law also imposes requirements concerning association meetings and budgets, and the governing documents may add additional procedures. Depending on how the project is funded and the assessment is structured, those requirements may need to be considered as part of the process. For a significant assessment, clear communication with owners should begin before the assessment is approved. No owner wants to be surprised by a large, unexpected bill. The board should give owners reasonable notice of the proposed project and assessment, explain why the work is needed and how the proposed assessment will be calculated, and provide any meeting or voting information required by the governing documents or Utah law. Once the assessment is properly approved, the board should adopt a written resolution identifying the project, the total amount being assessed, each owner’s share, payment deadlines, available payment options, and how any association financing will work. Providing clear information before the assessment is adopted, followed by clear documentation after approval, can reduce confusion, owner frustration, and disputes over the assessment.
Using an Association Loan to Give Owners More Time to Pay
One of the practical challenges with a large special assessment is that not every owner has substantial cash readily available. An association loan can sometimes make the assessment more manageable. Instead of waiting for every owner to pay the entire assessment before beginning the project, the association may borrow the funds needed to complete the work and use assessment payments to repay the loan. Owners who are able to pay their assessment in full may be permitted to do so, while owners who need additional time may be offered a longer payment schedule. This approach can be particularly useful when repairs cannot reasonably wait but the board is concerned about the financial impact of a large assessment on individual owners. It can give owners more flexibility without forcing the association to delay necessary work while it waits for assessment payments to come in. Before offering a payment over time option, the board should determine the following:
- Whether owners may prepay their share.
- How interest and financing costs will be allocated.
- Whether owners who pay immediately can avoid some or all financing costs.
- What happens to an unpaid assessment balance if an owner sells.
- What happens if an owner fails to make the required payments.
The assessment documents and the loan documents should address these issues consistently.
Be Careful About What the Lender Is Asking For
A lender’s loan documents are naturally written to protect the lender. That does not mean every provision is appropriate for every association. Association loan agreements may contain restrictions affecting the association’s financial decisions for years after the loan closes. A lender may seek provisions requiring the association to maintain or increase assessments, limiting the use of reserve funds, restricting additional borrowing or expenditures, assigning assessment income, or requiring lender consent before certain financial decisions are made. Some of those protections may be reasonable but other lender protections may go considerably further than necessary. The more important question is whether the board actually has the authority to make the promises contained in the loan documents. If the declaration requires owner approval for certain assessment decisions, for example, the board should be cautious about signing an agreement promising the lender that the board will make those decisions on its own. That is why reviewing an association loan should involve more than comparing interest rates and repayment terms. The lender’s covenants, collateral provisions, assignment of assessment income, consent rights, default remedies, and other restrictions should be compared against the association’s governing documents before the loan is signed.
Getting It Right Before the Documents Are Signed
Special assessments are difficult for owners even when everyone agrees that the underlying project is necessary. A board is in a much stronger position when it can clearly explain why the assessment is needed, how each owner’s share was calculated, how the assessment was authorized, and what payment options are available. It is also far easier to correct a problem with a proposed assessment or negotiate an unreasonable loan provision before the assessment is imposed or the loan closes. Once the assessment has been adopted or the financing documents have been signed, the association’s options may be much more limited. Miller Harrison works with Utah HOA and condominium boards throughout this process. We review governing documents, identify the approval procedures required for special assessments, prepare assessment resolutions and owner notices, and review and negotiate association loan documents. If your association is considering a major repair project, special assessment, or association loan, involving counsel early can help ensure that the assessment and financing are structured together, properly authorized, and clearly communicated before the board moves forward. This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. The requirements applicable to a particular HOA or condominium association depend on Utah law and the association’s specific declaration, bylaws, articles, and other governing documents. Associations should consult qualified legal counsel regarding their particular circumstances.
Being Proactive on HOA Repairs and Funding Them
HOA or Condo board members may have anxiety about making repairs to association common area and just as importantly—how to fund those repairs. In reality, many community associations may be apprehensive to get a contractor or vendor out and make repairs, large or small. What results is that maintenance is delayed until it’s too late, major repairs must be made, and the community has to spend more than they would have from the get-go. Why aren’t repairs made proactively? Why isn’t the up-keep better? It’s all about the money.
Understanding how to properly fund repairs isn’t just good governance; it’s a legal responsibility under Utah law that protects your community’s property values, allows associations to plan for the future, and prepare financially for emergencies. Plus, this keeps association members happy with a well-maintained community.
This guide breaks down the three primary financial mechanisms available to your association and the board: (1) annual budgets, (2) reserve accounts, and (3) special assessments.
What is the Annual Budget (or Operating Budget)?
A board may think that the operating budget is a catch-all for any expense that arises. But an operating budget must be more—it must be dedicated to the predictable, ongoing administration of the association. Utah law requires boards to prepare and adopt a budget at least annually and present it to the members. See Utah Code § 57-8-7.6 and § 57-8a-215.
What repairs can this budget be used for?
The operating budget is designed for day-to-day operations and routine upkeep. It covers regular cleaning, utilities, and minor, predictable repairs. For example, if a landscaper needs to be paid for upkeep, a sprinkler system needs adjusting, or a broken lobby door lock needs replacement, those funds come from the operating budget.
What is the Reserve Account?
Many boards think reserve funding is simple: save extra money, spend it when you need it. There’s actually more to it. By law, reserve funds can only be used for specific repairs (explained below). Boards must conduct a formal reserve analysis every six years and review or update it every three years. Furthermore, the board is legally required to maintain reserve funds in a separate account.
What repairs can the reserve be used for?
Utah law dictates that reserve funds are strictly for repairing, replacing, or restoring common areas and facilities that have a useful life of 3 years or more, and a remaining useful life of less than 30 years that cannot reasonably be funded from the annual or operating budget (such as, roofs, asphalt, or exterior siding). Pro-tip: A low-hanging fruit for a cost-effective repair from the reserve account could be new paint on the association’s exterior. Check out the podcast “HOA Insights: Common Sense for Common Areas” Episode 161 for more.
What are special assessments?
Even with the best operating budget and fully funded reserves, disasters happen and unforeseen capital deficits arise. This could be a major concrete repair after years of neglect or replacement of roofing after a storm. Special assessments are one-time additional charges levied on a lot or unit owner to cover these major, unfunded community repairs.
What is the role an attorney can play in advising boards on budgeting?
When there is a funding shortfall or a scary major repair, boards have many problem-solving tools at their disposal.
An attorney plays a vital role in interpreting Utah law and the Declaration or CC&Rs, advising boards on the annual budgets, budget approval, establishing and maintaining reserve accounts, the exact voting procedures required to pass a special assessment, and preventing the illegal commingling of funds. Furthermore, when owners fail to pay these carefully planned assessments, an attorney ensures that collection efforts, including the perfection of liens and potential foreclosures, are executed legally and effectively.
