News
The HOA Annual Meeting
‘Tis the Season for Utah HOA Annual Meetings!
By: Douglas C. Shumway, Esq.
Almost all homeowners associations in Utah are organized as non-profit corporations, and as such, Utah law requires such associations to hold at least one membership meeting per year. UCA 16-6a-701. This meeting is commonly referred to as the annual meeting. Associations oftentimes hold multiple meetings throughout the year. The annual meeting, however, is specifically required by statute, and it provides an association’s members the opportunity to receive a recap of the association’s activities from the preceding year, as well as a snap shot of the association’s activities for the upcoming year. The annual meeting also provides an association’s members an opportunity to chime in and make recommendations for the operation of the association, as well as to participate in the vote to elect an association’s newest members of its board of directors.
A homeowners association’s annual meeting provides an association the opportunity to address two additional requirements of Utah law that apply to homeowners associations. First, an association’s board of directors is required to adopt an annual budget and to provide the association’s members a summary of the adopted budget. UCA 57-8a-215. The summary provides the association’s members information on the association’s recurring expenses (i.e. landscaping, utilities, security, etc.), as well as any significant or unusual expenditures (i.e. resurfacing a pool, reroofing buildings, installing playground equipment, etc.) that the association intends to make during the year. In addition, if the association’s governing documents do not expressly authorize the Board to adopt an annual budget, the annual meeting provides the association’s members the opportunity to ratify the budget.
Second, and as part of the budget process, homeowners association’s board of directors is required to complete a reserve analysis of the costs to repair, maintain and replace the common area and facilities that have a useful life of between 3 – 30 years. UCA 57-8-7.5; UCA 57-8a-211. The association board must include a line item in the budget for reserve contributions, and the board must provide owners the opportunity to veto the reserve line-item amount proposed. If the owners do not veto such reserve provision by a 51% vote of the entire membership within 45 days of the board’s adopting of the budget, the proposed budget shall be considered adopted. Id.
As mentioned above, a homeowners association may hold meetings in addition to its annual meeting throughout the year. But if there is only one association meeting that you intend to sit in on during the year, plan on attending the annual meeting as it is oftentimes the most informative and most important meeting of the year.
HOAs, Contracts – A Checklist and Basic Guide
By Tyler LaMarr, Community Association Lawyer
Vendor Contracts – A Checklist of Key Provisions
Samuel Goldwyn said that “an oral contract isn’t worth the paper it is written on.” Unfortunately, the same can be said for many written contracts. The purpose of this brief article is to identify key provisions that should be included in association contracts. A well written contract can reduce liability exposure, reduce the risk of litigation, and help ensure that associations meet their objectives.
Term/Duration
A good contract will detail relevant timeframes and answer the following questions: (a) When does the contract become effective? (b) What is the deadline for completion of work? (c) How long will the contract remain in force? (d) Are party notification requirements time sensitive? (e) Is the contract auto-renewing, and if so, when, and for how long? (f) Do material terms (i.e. price) change throughout the effective date of the contract?
Deadlines and effective dates are commonly disputed; these disputes can often be avoided with clearly identified term and duration provisions.
Termination/Escape Route
Association’s frequently contact legal counsel seeking an escape route after becoming dissatisfied with vendor service. A good contract will provide an out for an unsatisfied association. Such provisions should include details on how to terminate, including the proper point of contact, the requisite advance notice (if any), an opportunity to cure, etc. At times it is in the association’s interests to clearly articulate grounds for termination; whereas, in some cases an association may wish to retain discretion to terminate without cause.
Associations should resist rushing into agreements that appear to be informal (i.e. bids, proposals, estimates), which may in fact have all the necessary elements to constitute a binding contract. While the focus is often on the initial execution of the contract, associations should consider important provisions that are often absent in less formal agreements.
Insurance/ Indemnification
Association directors have a fiduciary duty to the association and its members to use reasonable judgment in carrying on association business. Thus, when negotiating and executing contracts boards should always consider the inherent risks and include contract provisions to account for accidents or otherwise injurious conduct or events. Qualified vendors will be insured and will be prepared to provide proof of insurance at the association’s request.
Associations should (a) request proof of insurance, (b) ask about the coverage provided, (c) include a contract term requiring minimum insurance limits, and(d) establish that failure to maintain adequate insurance constitutes a material breach of the contract. Association’s should also consider seeking indemnification from vendors/contractors, and should consult with legal counsel to take steps to protect directors’ and association interests.
Attorney’s Fees
Contract disputes can be very costly to litigate. Litigation expenses often prohibit an association from seeking court assistance to enforce contract terms. As such, a good contract should include an attorney’s fee provision, which allows a prevailing association to recover court costs, expenses, and attorney’s fees in addition to damages. Costly litigation should be avoided if possible; however, attorney’s fees provisions often bring additional clout to out of court negotiations because of the prospect for attorney’s fees liability if cooperative negotiations break down.
Seek Legal Counsel
There is no one-size-fits-all contract. Associations are wise to consult legal counsel up front to avoid costly disputes later. Expending some association resources for competent legal counsel can save the association time, headaches, and money in the long run.
HOAs, Pets, and Assistance Animals
By Tyler LaMarr, Community Association Lawyer
We all know someone whose dog or cat is much more than just a pet. Well, for purposes of the Fair Housing Act, they may be right. Community associations must be careful as they adopt rules and regulations regarding animal restrictions because it is easy to run afoul of federal laws like the Fair Housing Act (FHA) or the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), which provide homeowners with special rights.
Generally speaking community associations can adopt and enforce animal restrictions including an outright ban on all pets. However, certain animals are not considered “pets” under federal law. For example, seeing eye dogs for the blind are considered service animals – not pets – and therefore cannot be banned by the association’s rules. Less obvious examples include companion or comfort animals for people who suffer from a disability such as post traumatic stress syndrome – such comfort and companion animals also are not considered “pets” under federal law and cannot be banned from the community.
Not surprisingly, some residents try to overcome community pet restrictions by making a bogus claim that their pet is needed to ameliorate a disability. Community managers are well within their rights to require proof from a medical professional or some other qualified person who can verify the existence of a disability and confirm the need for an assistance animal. Unlike service animals, companion and comfort animals are not required to be certified with special training. Also, keep in mind assistance animals are not always cats and dogs – disability laws require reasonable accommodations for miniature ponies, pot-belly pigs, ferrets, or any other animal that improves the mental or physical health of a disabled person. Furthermore, while the Association must provide reasonable accommodations for assistance animals, the Association need not tolerate nuisances from such animals. For example, nuisance rules regarding feces and excessive noise apply equally to assistance animals and ordinary pets.
Remember that penalties for an FHA or ADA violation can be expensive, and can garner negative publicity for the HOA so it is always a good idea to consult with an attorney to ensure that Association rules are in compliance with federal and state law.
