How far should my HOA’s architectural guidelines go?

When an HOA is formed, its creators have to decide how much power and discretion the Board should be given regarding the appearance of the homes in the community. A strong architectural review committee (also known as an “ARC”) can be one of a community’s greatest assets, but it can also be a source of constant administrative headaches. Should an HOA’s Board or ARC have the power to review and approve all home modifications, dictate the exact shade of exterior paint, and determine which trees you can plant, or should the HOA take a more relaxed approach? There are pros and cons of each approach, and Utah statutes provide only a little guidance on the limits of a Board’s architectural review authority.

 

Why would an HOA prefer stricter HOA guidelines?

When utilized correctly, robust architectural guidelines provide significant benefits to a community. Notably, strict guidelines can generate visual harmony throughout the neighborhood and help the community create and maintain a distinct character. Close your eyes and picture a street in Daybreak. Not very difficult to picture, is it? That is because strong guidelines dictate the colors of the homes, the permitted vegetation, and the modifications permitted.

Additionally, without guidelines, there is very little power to stop an owner from painting their house puke green or building a massive, permanent tree house in the front yard. If you live in an area with beautiful natural views, strict guidelines can prevent owners from erecting structures that block your view or restrict your natural light. Consistency and predictability can help protect property values in your community, and buyers are often willing to pay a premium to know that their neighbor’s yard won’t suddenly become a junk yard overwhelmed with weeds and garbage.

 

That all sounds great – why wouldn’t I want strict guidelines?

While many people value and appreciate the appearance of a neighborhood with a clean and uniform aesthetic, others find that strict architectural guidelines strip away the homes of any sense of individuality or creativity. If you have the money to build your dream home, why should your neighbors be allowed to have any input in the construction process? Why should a set of arbitrary guidelines be able to dictate your rights to build on your property? Unfortunately, by purchasing a home in an HOA with strong architectural control guidelines, you accepted contractual obligations to comply with those guidelines as interpreted by the Board or ARC. If your desire is to build a unique, personal home with no restrictions or impediments from your neighbors, your best bet is to buy a lot outside of HOA control.

From the perspective of the Board, it can also be a taxing and difficult task to police the appearance of the homes in your neighborhood. Many HOAs already find it difficult to find owners that are willing to volunteer to run for the Board. Adding in ARC guidelines only adds an additional hurdle to the task as you must become familiar with those guidelines and implement them uniformly. If you don’t, you risk forfeiting the guidelines altogether and could have owners alleging that you violated your duties as a Board member. Worse, your neighbors may personally blame you for simply enforcing the HOA’s policies. This can create tension in communities and often leads to litigation.

Often, HOA Boards and ARCs choose to outsource their reviews of complex architectural plans to someone with more expertise, such as an architect or structural engineer. This costs money. While these costs can sometimes be passed on to the homeowner submitting the application, it (at the very least) adds a layer of administrative friction and expense. This should be clearly spelled out in the governing documents or ARC guidelines for the community. If an owner brings a lawsuit related to architectural guidelines, the best way for an HOA to prevail is to have clear, defined guidelines that grant wide discretion to the Board or ARC. Even with those clear guidelines in place, though, litigation is costly for an HOA and only further increases neighborhood division.

 

Understanding the limits of Utah law.

If you’re thinking of tightening your community’s architectural guidelines, it’s important to understand the things that Utah law strictly prohibits an HOA from enforcing. The Utah Condominium Ownership Act (Utah Code Ann. § 57-8) and the Community Association Act (Utah Code Ann. § 57-8a) form the statutory basis for limiting the Board’s authority. Have an experienced attorney review any proposed guidelines in the context of these statutes before you commit to any new rules. For starters, though, there are a few provisions that the law is clear on.

Importantly, Utah Code § 57-8a-218 and § 57-8a-231 state that an HOA cannot, by rule, prohibit water-wise landscaping. Furthermore, an association cannot restrict the conversion of a grass park strip to water-wise landscaping or prohibit low water use on lawns during drought conditions. State law also heavily restricts an HOA’s ability to ban solar panels on an owner’s property, though reasonable guidelines on placement are allowed. Similarly, an HOA cannot generally prohibit satellite dish installation, but they can guide placement. Finally, Utah law also includes restrictions on an HOA’s ability to stop owners from displaying political, religious, and holiday signs (again, though, an HOA may adopt reasonable time, place, and manner restrictions). Most importantly, all rules must treat all owners equally, so do not adopt any provisions that you are not willing to live by as an owner.

 

Conclusion

If you want to experience the visual benefits of architectural guidelines without the heartburn of enforcing those guidelines, finding the sweet spot between aesthetic chaos and an overbearing ARC is key. If your community’s architectural guidelines are outdated, overly complex to enforce, or out of compliance with current Utah law, you should reach out to an HOA attorney today to get information on how to amend and replace those guidelines.